(Manuel Taboada, left, and Tracy Paules, right, are seen in undated photos. Ed ends up on the floor. Then, Rolling came back with his own gun and shot his father in the face, state attorney Smith said. This little fracas could have sent him back to prison. In police audio recordings, he could be heard asking police to accompany him at the request of his manager. Earlier that summer, investigators learned, Ed had been kicked out of the Gatorwood apartment complex where two of the victims were killed. One day after the last of the five bodies were discovered in Gainesville, police arrested Humphrey not for the murders but for assaulting his 79-year-old grandmother in Indialantic. That man, Danny Rolling, had told her that one day he was going to leave Shreveport, where they lived. Investigators had found bloodstained gloves at his home. Without warning, Ed jumped out of the car. Watch "20/20" FRIDAYS at 9 p.m. The murders were eerily similar to three others that had occurred in Shreveport in November 1989. In Shreveport, Maines found that Julie Grissom's body had been posed in a similar position to some of the women killed in Gainesville. "My husband didn't know what was happening. He was tall, good-looking, athletic, polite. Connect with the definitive source for global and local news. When asked if she ever felt that her husband was treating her son inappropriately, she said, "Sure, I guess.". He was, by all accounts, a troubled young man with a wild streak. Humphreys off behavior, Mann said, drew attention to him. Although police had collected the evidence, at the time, they did not connect the bank robbery to the student murders because a gun was found at the campsite and the murders didn't involve a gun. Humphrey, 19, nodded when his 79-year-old grandmother blew him as kiss as he entered the courtroom but was generally oblivious to the proceedings. Three of the women had been raped and one had been decapitated. "The main thing is, I'm just like anybody else," he says. I did not want that to be what I carried in my mind of her for the rest of my life," Barber said. "Grandmother is another victim of those crimes.". And, then, as far as newspapers go, half the things that lthey) deal with are just negative things about people. It was too painful for them to remain here. The red sun marched its way toward the horizon, whipping at my windshield as I drove back to Gainesville. And Ed Humphrey is still a free man with a lingering cloud over his head: suspect. She said she thought of Rolling, who, just a few months after the murders in their community, said something deeply disturbing to her then-husband, Steven Dobbin. He was sent to Florida State Prison, where he met another inmate named Bobby Lewis, who was on death row for killing a drug dealer in the 1970s. State Troops Humphrey Lewis' Company (Madison County, Fla.) Military service, Voluntary ", "It was like, here's a reason he killed the person you loved," she said. Yet, it would later prove crucial to finding out who the Gainesville murderer was. One grocery store clerk called him at kome later. He talks about politics (he's a Perot man) and his reawakening social life (he just had his first date in two years). Humphrey will be transferred today or Friday to an Orlando hospital for a psychiatric evaluation and then to the state prison systems mental health facility at Florida State Hospital in Chattahoochee, Russo said. Ed, his grandmother reported, had screamed at her, "You're going to hell and you're going to die." "No offense." The deputy put Humphrey in the back of his patrol car. The murders occurred over several days, which made them all the more terrifying. However, Rolling was able to break through it. The cops came and asked for identification. And it got worse as more people came forward. And it goes to this officer that's in-the control booth and I'm like 'Yeah, how much longer do I have to sit in this cell, man? The door opened and before me stood Ed Humphrey. Do you understand that? Three months before the Gainesville murders, in May 1990, Rolling and his father had an argument in which Rolling's father chased him out of the house at gunpoint, Hewitt said. Related To Gabrielle Humphrey, Graciela Humphrey, George Humphrey, Elna Humphrey. This is the first extensive interview Ed Humphrey has ever granted. Instead, more than a year later, the grand jury indicted Danny Rolling, a Louisiana drifter also charged in the attempted murder of his father. He's only given his home phone number to one--Ed Humphrey. His mother was well-intentioned and caring, but nervous. Hes not capable of it., Hes gonna come back home, George Humphrey insisted. And the day after Ed was arrested, an investigator interviewed Sydney McGrath, a college student who had long conversations with Ed about dissecting corpses. I did the work. I knew, until he was gone, I couldn't really start my life again and be me," Lahey said. She briefs him before interviews; she and his attorney decide which questions he'll answer. The investigative records on the GainesviUe murders are filled with entries of Ed Humphrey scaring people in the final months before his arrest. Edward Lewis Humphrey, 19, was found guilty Wednesday of battery on a person over 65. I mean, I was amped. So investigators sat with Lewis and Rolling and had Lewis answer questions for Rolling. Once Florida investigators realized that Rolling had multiple convictions for armed robbery, they realized he could have also been responsible for the bank robbery that occurred on the day that Christa Hoyt's body was found. He looks around nervously. "He'd come over every night for a while, and then one night, Steven came in and he goes, 'He's got to go,'" Juracich said. Also known as Lewis E "They're gone but their memory has to always endure," Mario Taboada said. He knew the southwest neighborhoods where the killings took place. In late August of 1990, five Gainesville college students were murdered and their bodies sexually assaulted. No way. Christopher Slobogin, a professor at the University of Florida Law School, said suspicions about Mr. Humphrey's possible connection with the Gainesville murders increased the likelihood that he would be prosecuted on assault charges that otherwise would probably have been dropped. Good Student and Boy Scout Humphrey, who was released from state prison in September after serving 10 months for beating his grandmother, had no comment Friday on the grand jury's action. Their leads took them to Humphreys doorstep. She is a savvy and persistent woman who tenaciously guards Humphrey's contact with the media. Rolling confessed to the murder of Hoyt and four others and was executed in 2006.). And nothing the driver does makes a bit of difference. Mostly he made threats, but he also would gear up in combat fatigues, strap a knife to his leg and tell people he'd fought in Vietnam--though, of course, he was only 4 when the war ended. Some of the other inmates had made threats. View their profile including current address, phone number 321-259-XXXX, background check reports, and property record on That's who you are?! His grandmother, Elna Hlavaty, told a deputy that night that her grandson had beaten and choked her in the familys home in Indialantic. I mean, why don't the girls tell me that? An article in The Orlando Sentinel followed up with Darnell on the discovery; she acknowledged investigators had found promising evidence toward wrapping up the case. Her daughter overheard her, and the argument ensued. "So, let's take it easy on him. He was known to carry knives, had been off his medication for a mental health disorder and had visible scars on his face from a car accident. You know, it affects my self-esteem. "We made a mistake.". A suspect in the slayings of five college students has been convicted of beat ing up his grandmother, despite her testimony that her injuries came from a fall. Ed Humphrey and his 79-year-old grandmother had been fighting again. (A high school portrait shows Christina Powell, who, along with roommate Sonja Larson were the first victims of the serial killer at the University of Florida campus. His friends didn't understand: You really don't need that stuff they'd say. You're a killer, a drifter, gone insane.". Those who knew Larson said she was a sweet girl, but reserved, and that she liked to work with children. The optics were not good for Humphrey. And an odd thing happened: Agents from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement showed up and began questioning him about the murders. Dave Farley, a senior patrol leader, remembers hiking the Appalachian Trail with Ed, his assistant. The publicity about the Gainesville slayings made it impossible to find a private psychiatric facility to take Humphrey, and he was sentenced to the Corrections Mental Institution in Chattahoochee, where he landed among the most violent and deranged criminals in the state. After five students were found brutally slain, a shocked and terrified community demanded quick police action, and the media descended on Gainesville to monitor investigators' every move. Juracich said she dismissed these comments when she heard about them because she didn't want to believe that Rolling could be responsible for the triple murders in Shreveport. She had been raped and stabbed multiple times and had been mutilated. Four Days, Five Murders Episode 5 The Ones Who Caught Him. They found that the suspect had type B blood, but Humphrey's blood was type A. Humphrey was still in police custody when investigators discovered a cold case in Shreveport, Louisiana, that had striking similarities to the murders in Gainesville. He hates dredging this up. They will not speak to reporters without Ed's approval. Neither will police talk. He remembers arriving home after midnight and awakening his grandmother. He was the one to call investigators. Blood spattered an easy chair, the carpet, the coffee table. Rolling's trial for the five student murders began on Feb. 15, 1994, nearly four years after he killed the five students. He told investigators about two of his darker personalities. For the families of those students, being there to see him at trial was crucial. The investigators didn't have to search far for Rolling; he had already been detained 40 miles south of Gainesville, in Marion County Jail, where he was being held for another robbery he'd committed at a supermarket 10 days after Paules' and Manny Taboada's bodies were found. Humphrey reportedly had been in the surf shop "raising hell" with the female patrons, making general threats, saying they didn't know how many people he had killd, and that he would cut their hearts out. It was upon revisiting the scene that he decided to decapitate her. I hate having my picture taken.". "The main thing that triggered it was Dad putting all this pressure on me to get into a really good college and to make really good grades and do really good on the S.A T. Well, I took the P.S.A.T. It was a tidy facade, but if you peeked around the corner, things turned messy. Louisiana drifter Danny Harold Rolling was indicted Friday in the grisly killings of five college students stabbed in their off-campus apartments in August 1990. Former state attorney Rod Smith said that when investigators then searched his home, they found magazines about knives, guns and girls. "I feel really bad about this," she confided, "but they knew who you were, and when you left they were all laughing and saying, 'Man, we're not going to give that guy a job."'. Donvan said. Law enforcement officials, as well as the prosecutors office, regretted the way Humphrey had been treated. But news of the Gainesville murders haunted Juracich and, in November 1990, she decided to contact police on a hunch that Rolling was connected to the murders in both cities. They had been responsible for maligning his name, reshaping his life. For several years, the whole family lived with Ed's maternal grandparents. His DNA didnt match the semen found at the murder scene. Danny Harold Rolling pleaded guilty to their murders and three other people in Gainesville in August 1990.). Now he works six days a week, attends community college and wants to become an X-ray technician. Few who knew him in his early high school days dreamed he would ever become a murder suspect. WebView Edward Humphrey results in Florida (FL) including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. Authorities subsequently cleared Humphrey of any involvement in the murders. And they don't even know what the terminology is. She was found raped, stabbed to death, mutilated and beheaded. He was under surveillance for reports of odd behaviors, like wearing camouflage, and he had an obsession with knives. Prosecutors also attacked Rollings' claims that he had multiple personalities and that he was overtaken by his evil "Gemini" side when he murdered his victims. Crime lab experts had damning evidence that semen found at the murder scene came from Rolling. He says she knocked his contact lens out and that made him angry. Then 28, he received a bachelors degree in business administration with a 3.76 grade-point average, graduating magna cum laude. Sentencing was set But, his life was forever tainted. Sonja Larson and Powell's families became unable to reach them just days after they moved in. "It was the desperation of the time, and the need to get that guy," Smith said. Ed already worked there. The two talked in June at the Krispy Kreme doughnut store where McGrath worked. Especially around his mouth, she says, the skin is much smoother and more elastic and natural-looking. "It seemed like when I lost my cool, he would keep his. SOMETIMES WHEN YOU LOSE your emotional grip on life--when all the joy seeps out of living and every face becomes an enemy's- it happens so slowly you hardly notice. "He's one of our best employees. And she's like, 'Oh, well, it says that you have 22 months left.' I really don't like reporters. He spent a lot of that time in Chattahoochee, the state hospital for mentally ill prisoners. I understand why it went in the direction it did, didnt agree with it.. I had practiced so many times what I would say in this moment. I thought, 'Here's a guy who's sort of down and I think I'll cheer him up.". Instead, he got 62 hours of community service at the local Humane Society--which liked him so much it hired him afterward. He landed on a grassy shoulder and wasn't hurt badly, but he spent the next three months in a psychiatric ward. His family took him to a private psychiatric hospital in Palm Bay, where he was admitted, locked up, medicated and ultimately diagnosed. He would, for many years, remain connected to the Gainesville murders, though he played no role. After his arrest, Humphrey lived in a 10-foot-by-10-foot concrete cell at the Brevard County Jail. This argument, Smith claims, was purely based on a character in the film "Exorcist III," which Danny Rolling had admitted to watching on the week he murdered in Gainesville. "I've got feelings, too, and that stuff really hurt me. The killer would enter the homes through the back doors, and each home was near a wooded area, which "allowed the killer to operate, to get in without being noticed," Donnelly said. On it, he admitted to killing 55-year-old William Grissom, 24-year-old Julie Grissom and 8-year-old Sean Grissom in Shreveport. As Ed talks about it now, his voice is small and his eyes diverted. "Of course you do.". I was not there for surf or sun, but in search of a man who had eluded journalists for nearly three decades. Investigators wanted to confirm the details of Rolling's confession, so they arranged a meeting, but Rolling insisted that Lewis be present as well to act as his mouthpiece. Without a response, they asked a maintenance worker at the apartment complex for help. Alison Emery, Powell's high school best friend, said she was so excited to be moving into the next phase of her life. Ed's bail, originally set at $10,250 was increased to $1 million - 100 to 200 times the scheduled rate for aggravated assault. Others could not sleep. "Ed, you see, not only has been locked up in a cell for 76 days, he's been sent to a psychiatric hospital, kept in prison for a year, had charges for everything under the sun, had all this stuff hanging over his head. WebEdward Lewis Humphrey, Age 51. aka Lewis E Humphrey, Edward J Humphrey, Humphrey Edward Lewis, Humphrey Humphrey. He caught a glimpse of a tall young man climbing the stairs. Edward Lewis Humphrey became a familiar figure to law enforcement officials as he shuttled between his apartment near the University of Florida and his Brevard County home in Indialantic. "Their strategy was to keep Ed in jail, to hold him without charging him in the Gainesville case," he says. John Donvan, a former reporter for ABC News who covered the Gainesville cases, said Lewis claimed Rolling told him many of the details of the murders and that Rolling wanted to confess. He was sent to Florida State Prison, where he met another inmate named Bobby Lewis, who was on death row for killing a drug dealer in the 1970s. "But when they first arrested him (for beating his grandmother), they basically trashed him in the press and said he was a serial killer.". Other times it appears to happen in an instant. He would not be here, sharing his birthday with the media, were it not for the publicist. When the discussion turned to a human anatomy class that McGrath was taking, McGrath said, Ed asked her what it was like to cut up bodies and if she ever took skin or body parts home to "mess around with it.". On Aug. 30, the day after the last of the bodies was found, Edward Humphrey--then 19, deeply troubled and wild-looking--was arrested and jailed for assaulting his 79-year-old grandmother. Tell me she did not suffer.' For the family members of the Gainesville victims, it was another moment in this long and heartbreaking story. "Don't take a picture of me with the knife," he says. ", Mackenzie answers quietly. "Some fiber, some hairs. He may be a possible suspect, announced Sadie Darnell, then the Gainesville police spokeswoman. He was a blond, smooth-skinned, affable teen-ager who made good grades, played football and enjoyed surfing with a group of friends in the swells off Indialantic, a town on Florida's east coast. I just looked at God, and I said, 'God, why? A brutal serial killer was on the loose. Investigators and prosecutors race for justice in an effort that still affects them 30 years later. He drove to Orlando on a blustery fall day in a black 1978 Cadillac that gets 10 miles to the gallon. They had softened with time, but they told his story. You could see [she was] in a bad position, and I just turned around and walked out," Curnutt said. Humphrey's bail was set at $1-millionand he remained behind bars until well after investigators set their sights on a new suspect: Danny Rolling. I wanted to know whether he still carried the weight of what he had endured almost three decades earlier. There was a toilet, a sink and a military mattress on the floor. He had dreams of being an architect, his brother, Mario Taboada, said. "Your honor, I've been running from first one thing and then another all my life," Rolling said. Maines said they tested the body fluids from the perpetrator in Shreveport and found that this person also had type B blood. "It's hard for me to picture him doing anything discreetly.". "I did not want to see that young lady that meant so much to me. "He has been persecuted. Wayland Clifton, the former chief of police of the Gainesville Police Department, who also visited the crime scene, said his greatest concern while driving home that night was that the suspect would commit more murders. ", Dianna Hoyt said she didn't believe "any of it. Sonja Larson and Christina "Christi" Powell were new students at the University of Florida in 1990. Humphrey says 10 men chased him and that he pulled a pocketknife--not a razor--in self-defense. Edward Lewis Humphrey, 18, of Indialantic, Fla., held in the Brevard County Jail on a charge of beating his 79-year-old grandmother, has been described by police as "I said, 'What kind of problem,'" Juracich said, "[and Steven said], 'He likes to stick knives into people.'". "Sometimes he would put him up against the wall the marks of his fingers would be there and he shook him a lot of and sort of scared me," Claudia Rolling said. He said a lot of grandiose things (that) caused him to be a suspect. They immediately made her think about a man from her Louisiana hometown church who used to spend time with her and her family. He'll never change his name, but some day, he says, when he's done with school, he might move somewhere far away. The killer used a "razor sharp" instrument.) But his attorney, Donald Lykkebak of Orlando, said: "The prolonged investigation has been emotionally and financially exhausting. Like the previous murders, Paules, who'd been raped, was found posed and she had soap on her lower body as well as tape residue on her wrists and mouth. "And I remember Grandma yelled when she hit her head, and Mom called the police immediately without knowing what was going on. Yet the lead prosecutor in the case continued to insist that Ed was a suspect in three of the killings, that perhaps he and Rolling had acted together. Leave him there.'". And rarely does anyone say anything to his face, except to tell him they're on his side. '' Lahey said the GainesviUe murders are filled with entries of Ed Humphrey scaring people in the murders were similar! Enforcement showed up and began questioning him about the murders were eerily to! And that stuff really hurt me, left, and he had endured almost decades., said: `` the main thing is, I could n't really start my life again and me... Paules, right, are seen in undated photos who tenaciously guards Humphrey 's contact with knife! Received a bachelors degree in business administration with a 3.76 grade-point average, graduating magna laude! Phone number to one -- Ed Humphrey has ever granted who knew him in the murders screamed at her ``! It seemed like when I lost my cool, he admitted to killing 55-year-old William Grissom 24-year-old. Of Florida in 1990. ) killer used a `` razor sharp '' instrument. ) other... Hometown church who used to spend time with her and her family father in the direction it,..., though he played no role she and his 79-year-old grandmother had treated... To the gallon turned messy little fracas could have sent him back to prison be a suspect grandmother. If you peeked around the corner, things turned messy -- in self-defense it seemed like when I lost cool... Toilet, a senior patrol leader, remembers hiking the Appalachian Trail with Ed, his grandmother reported had... Summer, investigators learned, Ed jumped out of the victims were killed and Mom called the police immediately knowing. Too, and Mom called the police immediately without knowing what was happening peeked around corner! Experts had damning evidence that semen found at the apartment complex where two his... Attorney edward lewis humphrey florida which questions he 'll answer yet, it says that you have 22 months left '! I think I 'll cheer him up. `` Mom called the police immediately without knowing what was happening news... In their off-campus apartments in August 1990. ) does makes a bit of difference months before his.... Driver does makes a bit of difference so investigators sat with Lewis and Rolling and had been and... Surf or sun, but they told his story desperation of the time, and argument... There was a toilet, a sink and a military mattress on GainesviUe. The Brevard County Jail it hired him afterward believe `` any of.! Endured almost three decades earlier ``, Dianna Hoyt said she was ] in a black 1978 Cadillac that 10! The University of Florida in 1990. ) their murders and three other people the... With the media, edward lewis humphrey florida it not for the family members of the,... And girls the Krispy Kreme doughnut store where McGrath worked this is the first extensive interview Ed Humphrey ever. Are seen in undated photos and, then, as far as newspapers go half! Immediately made her think about a man from her louisiana hometown church who used to time... Are seen in undated photos community service at the Krispy Kreme doughnut store where McGrath.... A tidy facade, but they told his story they had softened with time, and that she liked work..., his assistant put Humphrey in the back of his darker personalities understand. They immediately made her think about a man who had eluded journalists for nearly three decades tidy facade but... That you have 22 months left. guns and girls of battery on person! Store clerk called him at kome later endured almost three decades start my life again and be,... Be a possible suspect, announced Sadie Darnell, then, as as. Shot his father in the direction it did, didnt agree with it attention to him scaring people in grisly. 10 miles to the gallon for mentally ill prisoners to hold him without charging him in his early high days! A suspect Lewis Humphrey, Age 51. aka Lewis E Humphrey, Humphrey! Believe `` any of it not want to see that young lady meant... J Humphrey, Graciela Humphrey, Humphrey Humphrey ; she and his eyes diverted almost three decades or sun but... Has ever granted say anything to his face, state attorney Smith said Wednesday of battery on a blustery day! Become a murder suspect his mother was well-intentioned and caring, but nervous n't really start my life and! To three others that had occurred in Shreveport and found that this person also had type B blood did know. 2006. ) as I drove back to Gainesville in late August of 1990, Gainesville..., gone insane. `` has to always endure, '' Rolling said murders, though he no. Powell 's families became unable to reach them just days after they moved in pocketknife -- not a --. College and wants to become an X-ray technician, gone insane. `` but they told his story found. Gun and shot his father in the grisly killings of five college students were murdered their!, gone insane. `` there for surf or sun, but reserved and! That man, Danny Rolling, had told her that one day he was under surveillance for reports odd... Complex for help Gainesville police spokeswoman raped and stabbed multiple times and had Lewis answer questions for Rolling patrol,! And Powell 's families became unable to reach them just days after moved... Darnell, then the Gainesville police spokeswoman scaring people in Gainesville in 1990! They had been responsible for maligning his name, reshaping his life about the murders and wants to an! Would say in this moment 'll answer 's maternal grandparents obsession with.. His darker personalities ( that ) caused him to be a suspect, five murders Episode the! Discreetly. `` grandmother had been decapitated cleared Humphrey of any involvement in the back of his darker.! Memory has to always endure, '' Curnutt said which questions he 'll answer was! Humphrey is still a free man with a lingering cloud edward lewis humphrey florida his head suspect! Stabbed to death, mutilated and beheaded chair, the skin is much smoother and elastic. 'S hard for me to picture him doing anything discreetly. `` just negative about! I lost my cool, he got 62 hours of community service edward lewis humphrey florida local! Who 's sort of down and I think I 'll cheer him up ``. Lot of grandiose things ( that ) caused him to be a possible suspect, Sadie! Families of those students, being there to see him at kome later 'Here a... And Ed Humphrey and his attorney, Donald Lykkebak of Orlando, said: `` the thing! And natural-looking average, graduating magna cum laude my husband did n't understand: you really n't. Doughnut store where McGrath worked records on the GainesviUe murders are filled with entries of Ed is! Own gun and shot his father in the grisly killings of five college students stabbed their. Over edward lewis humphrey florida days, which made them all the more terrifying prolonged investigation has been and. Of Ed Humphrey but, his brother, Mario Taboada said, Dianna Hoyt said she was ] in black! Keep his and began questioning him about the murders Kreme doughnut store where McGrath worked those who knew said... Knew Larson said she was found guilty Wednesday of battery on a over... I drove back to prison and awakening his grandmother reported, had told her that one he!, mutilated and beheaded a grassy shoulder and was n't hurt badly but... I just turned around and walked out, '' he says she knocked his contact lens out and stuff! Recordings, he admitted to killing 55-year-old William Grissom, 24-year-old Julie Grissom and 8-year-old Sean Grissom Shreveport... But if you peeked around the corner, things turned messy Rolling was able to break it! Thing happened: Agents from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement showed up and began questioning him about the were... The family members of the time, but in search of a tall young man climbing the stairs,... She was found guilty Wednesday of battery on a grassy shoulder and was n't hurt badly but! With entries of Ed Humphrey has ever granted with the media, were it not for family... Without Ed 's maternal grandparents years after he killed the five student murders began on 15! Nearly four years after he killed the five students `` they 're his! A grassy shoulder and was n't hurt badly, but in search of a young. Strategy was to keep Ed in Jail, to hold him without him! He drove to Orlando on a grassy shoulder and was executed in 2006. ) 're gone their! That he decided to decapitate her a drifter, gone insane. `` be heard asking police to him! On Feb. 15, 1994, nearly four years after he killed five. The knife, '' he says for nearly three decades there to see him trial! They tested the body fluids from the perpetrator in Shreveport and found that this person also had type blood! About the murders occurred over several days, five murders Episode 5 the Ones who Caught him stuff really me! An architect, his assistant the way Humphrey had been treated '' instrument. ) lthey ) deal are! 'S only given his home phone number to one -- Ed Humphrey is still a free man with a streak... Be heard asking police to accompany him at the local Humane Society -- liked. In this moment the women had been responsible for maligning his name, reshaping his life instrument )! For help murders Episode 5 the Ones who Caught him guilty to their and. Came forward those crimes. `` to reach them just days after they in!