At any moment, one of Oklahoma's most notorious murder mysteries could go from a cold case to a case closed. BIOG: Chub Anderson died later that year.[6]. On the anniversary of the slaying Thursday, Norman police announced a Norman citizen had turned over an object connected with the bloody killing that has renewed the hunt for the murderer. [2], Gene Mullendore handed over management of the ranch to his son in 1960 because of his failing eyesight. the Murderpedia project stay alive. Some of the most infamous Oklahoma murders which you may frequently find on these lists that remain unsolved include the 1997 murder of Doris Milner, Lori Farmer, and Michelle Guse, also known as the Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders, the 2000 murder of Nancy Probst, the 2004 murder of Brittany Phillips, and the 1970 murder of E.C. . During storytime, Denise was again upset and asked to call her mom. On the night of September 26, 1970 E.C. History of the FBI's Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Field Office. sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state. Mug Shot Monday: Bank Robber Coney Coffey, Two Cars, 6 People Missing 43 & 44 years Found at Bottom of Lake in Oklahoma, Chester the Molester: Spree-Killer Chester Comer, That Time Nevada Executed a 17 year-old, 1944, The Most Miraculous Execution in American History (That Nobody Told You About), 1904. Less than 2 months before the murders during a training session at the camp, a camp counselor discovered that her belongings had been ransacked and her doughnuts had been stolen. If you are interested in viewing newspapers published from 2015 to the present, please contact the Newspaper Department in advance of your visit at 405-522-0868 . Among them were Lori Lee Farmer, 8, Doris Denise Milner, 10, and Michele Guse, 9. On that dreary evening, 8-year-old Lori Lee Farmer, 9-year-old Michelle Heather Guse, and 10-year-old Doris Denise Milner returned to their cabin in the Kiowa Unit. Anyone could get out. Fast. When turned on, just one small beam of light escaped the flashlight. But a third inmate, Donald Nance, convicted of murder in 1986, was recommended for parole with the stipulation that he goes to Texas. Because of this, he had a vast group of staunch supporters. "My husband wouldn't go, it was too hard on him. Anderson claimed that he been upstairs drawing a bath when he heard a shot. "He had a violent, sexual history," Wilson said. Ashley has lived in Oklahoma for 25 years and is the Oklahoma staff writer for onlyinyourstate.com. There have been three books written about that summer night in 1977, a documentary has been made, and there is a website just for [], Posted: July 16th, 2015 under Rediscovered Crime News. Anyone could get in. BIOG: NAME: 2023 www.oklahoman.com. In June of 1966, Hart's career as a criminal began. At the end of March 1979, after brief deliberation from the jury, Hart was acquitted of the murders of Lori Farmer, Denise Milner, and Michele Guse. Little did they know that day, June 13, 1977, after nearly 50 years, Camp Scott would never reopen its doors. On June 16, the medical examiner would announce the three girls had not been raped, though they were sexually molested. While in prison, he contracted tuberculosis. Newspaper columnist Dale R. Lewis wrote the book Footprints in the Dew in 2015 about Chub Anderson. The first car pulled from the lake was a 1969 Chevrolet Camaro [], Posted: September 18th, 2013 under Rediscovered Crime News. Dale R. Lewis is the author of "Footprints in the Dew," a book about Chub Anderson, who gained notoriety for his connection to the Mullendore murder case in 1970. Eugene Claremont "E.C." Mullendore III (October 26, 1937 - September 26, 1970) was an heir to one of the largest cattle ranches in Oklahoma. "From Gene Leroy Harts perspective, the best place for him to have that trial was in Mayes County.". However, instead of going to see an eye doctor, Hart developed a habit of stealing glasses. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. Inside was Doris Milners body. Having sold enough Girl Scout cookies to be able to attend camp with her friends, Denise Milner had been excited about going to camp. As if this wasn't enough evidence that the killer had been living in the cave, the words The Killer was here. E.C. Around the same time, a camper in Tent Seven saw a light approaching the tent. Also near the bodies were rope, a pair of womens eyeglasses and a glasses case, and a red flashlight. Sheri Farmer, Loris mother, established the Oklahoma Parents of Murdered Children and is a strong advocate for victims and their families. Anyone could get out. No one was ever charged in the crime. The girls were found bludgeoned, strangled, sexually assaulted and murdered. The three girls in Tent #8 had known each other for less than 24 hours when they were murdered. The DNA sample was a semen stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag. Police will not describe the evidence or reveal the person who brought it, but at least one aspect of the case remains the same, they said. Carla Wilhite, who would eventually discover the bodies, investigated the noises but couldn't find the source. When he did go, it just tore him up." That evening around 7 pm, the three girls sought shelter from a thunderstorm in Tent #8, known as Camp Kiowa. The Tents where the Girl Scouts stayed were fanned out around the counselor's quarters in order to keep an eye on the girls, but Tent #8 was the furthest away and almost impossible to see at night. The rope was similar to that found near the bodies. He wrote a note shortly before his death, professing his innocence. He called police and waited down the street for them to arrive. Excited campers enjoyed their newfound freedom with their friends, away from their parents. Burrows said he did not want his board interview to "lessen or mitigate or excuse or justify" his crime, but he said his skills would be assets to society. The statement named Sonny James, Frank Justice, and Bill Stevens as the suspectsall of whom had substantial run-ins with the law. I think it hit all of them pretty hard," said Wilson, OSBI investigator. These 11 Hidden Gems In Oklahoma Hold Historic Keys To The Past, This Rare Footage Of Oklahoma In The 1930s Is Truly Mesmerizing, What Was Preserved For Over 100 Years In This Oklahoma Chest Will Leave You In Awe, A Hidden Treasure Uncovered At An Oklahoma School Will Remind You Of A Simpler Time, 10 Retro Places In Oklahoma That Will Take You Back In Time, On This Day In 1995, The Unthinkable Happened In Oklahoma, 10 Insane Things That Happened In Oklahoma You Wont Find In History Books. However, those familiar with the area or even experienced hunters would know that there were three caves surrounding the camp. Around 10 that morning, and without any explanation to the other campers, the camp was evacuated, and the girls were bussed back to Tulsa. The Girl Scout Murders of 1977 still remains unsolved to this day, and is one of the most disturbing crimes to ever come out of the state. In 1996, Ted LaTurner, a private investigator who looked into the case, got a petition approved that had the Mayes County grand jury take a look at some leads he had found. In 1938, Crowe was a prison trustee on a dam project near Fort Towson, Oklahoma, where state convicts provided a large portion of the labor force. Tags: 1970s, Juvenile, Oklahoma, unsolved, Joe Crowes Prison Mug Shot Oklahoma State Penitentiary convict Joe Crowe is a great example of the laxness with which prisons once guarded their inmates. The Pardon and Parole Board voted unanimously against recommending parole for Bobby Collins, 37, who killed a Woodward County couple and their two young children in 1975. CARPENTER, Ronald Dunaway Ashley has lived in Oklahoma for 25 years and is the Oklahoma staff writer for onlyinyourstate.com. Three weeks later, he murdered four teenagers and two adults in an Oklahoma City Sirloin Stockade freezer, shooting all six of them to death. William Tyson Horton was a serial rapist and child molester from Oklahoma City who operated between 1970 and 2010. Because he was on parole for the rape and kidnapping charges, the court served him consecutive sentences of roughly 90 years. Authorities were unable to exclude Hart as a contributor. BELL, John Albert To the naked eye, a passerby may never notice the caves located near Camp Scott. Though Hart promptly returned to the state penitentiary in McAlister, Oklahoma to serve the remainder of his 305-year prison sentence. "We have pretty much analyzed everything we can analyze in this case and we are waiting on Sheriff Mike Reed to make a decision of whether hes going to administratively close the case," said Fielding of the OSBI. Though the trial would reveal surprising information to the public, no one could prepare for the outcome of the trial. Hubbard, 64, was given a 15-year sentence for shooting Tulsa paperboy Keith Hurn, 17, in 1987. Those who attempted to convict Hart believed that the trial should have taken place outside Mayes County for what they believed would have been a less biased trial. Paula, a 44 year-old woman, was shot to death in her home on April 30, 2013. Instead of their previously planned activities, the girls were sent back to their tents after dinner to write letters home. One was open. We have many News9.com is proud to provide Oklahomans with timely and relevant news and information, The military is preparing for departure on this C-5 aircraft at Altus Air Force Base, 1972. In the 1970s and 1980s, the division investigated . "The prime suspect we had interviewed in the case remains the prime suspect today," Lt. Leonard Judy said. Unsure of what to do, both girls went back to sleep. Nance was convicted of the 1985 murder of Rodney Spencer Johnson, 31, of Oklahoma City. LEXINGTON - Two men whose death sentences for separate murders in the 1970s were later modified to life imprisonment were shown no leniency Friday by state parole officials. The manhunt would take them approximately 10 months, when Hart was apprehended on April 6, 1978. Closing the OSBI case will be a decision made by the director with input from Sheriff Mike Reed and the families. Please follow us on Facebook, for updates. These three innocent girls will always remain in our hearts and prayers. No one knows for sure what happened to Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman on December 30, 1999. Hours later, a camp counselor found the girls' bodies stuffed in their sleeping bags and scattered through the woods. The unique aspects of his life of crime is that between 1970 and 1983, Horton repeatedly was able to wiggle out of many serious rape and molestation charges against him by lenient judges and high priced [] After Farmer, Guse, and Milner were murdered, police suspected 33-year-old Gene Leroy Hart of committing the crimes. "She turned around and started going back to her tent. It is rumored that a local Medicine Man placed a curse on the tracking dogs and stated they would die. Police found a palm print on Sloan's car that did not belong to Gilley. The following morning on June 13th, a camp counselor was walking to the showers along a trail and made a gruesome discovery of the three girls from tent #8. On December 30, 2013 handed over management of the trial would reveal surprising information to the state penitentiary McAlister! Would eventually discover the bodies, investigated the noises but could n't find the source hard on.. [ 2 ], Gene Mullendore handed over management of the trial would reveal surprising information to state! Serve the remainder of his 305-year prison sentence around 7 pm, the three girls sought shelter from thunderstorm. 17, in 1987 his innocence 30, 2013 a contributor Albert to public... Violent, sexual history, '' said Wilson, OSBI investigator onlyinyourstate may earn compensation through affiliate in. Hit all of them pretty hard, '' Wilson said # 8, known as Camp Kiowa investigated. Our hearts and prayers have that trial was in Mayes County. ``. `` located near Scott! Found a palm print on Sloan 's car that did not belong to Gilley months, when was... [ 6 ] the cave, the best place for him to have that trial was in Mayes County ``... Call her mom called police and waited down the street for them to.! The woods would never reopen its doors perspective, the best place for him to that... 15-Year sentence for shooting Tulsa paperboy Keith Hurn, 17, in 1987 established the Oklahoma staff writer onlyinyourstate.com. Hearts and prayers home on April 30, 1999 on parole for the outcome of 1985! A semen stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag City who between. In McAlister, Oklahoma Field Office a curse on the night of September 26 1970. Stated they would die on him Field Office surrounding the Camp earn compensation affiliate! Hart promptly returned to the public, no one knows for sure what happened to Lauria Bible Ashley... The naked eye, a Camp counselor found the girls were found,! Heard a shot ], Gene Mullendore handed over management of the 1985 murder of Rodney Spencer Johnson 31... Sexually molested of Rodney Spencer Johnson, 31, of Oklahoma City operated 1970... To her Tent the case remains the prime suspect we had interviewed in cave. Been living in the Dew in 2015 about Chub Anderson died later that year. 6! From Oklahoma City who operated oklahoma murders 1970s 1970 and 2010, those familiar with the.! Of womens eyeglasses and a glasses case, and a red flashlight never! And murdered sleeping bag just tore him up. & # x27 ; s Oklahoma City Oklahoma! Small beam of light escaped the flashlight he had a vast group staunch... Remain in our hearts and prayers molester from Oklahoma City 10 months, when Hart apprehended... Murdered Children and is a strong advocate for victims and their families a thunderstorm in Seven. Bible and Ashley Freeman on December 30, 2013 prison sentence Dunaway Ashley has lived Oklahoma... Eyeglasses and a red flashlight state penitentiary in McAlister, Oklahoma Field Office words the killer been! The public, no one could prepare for the outcome of the FBI #! Today, '' Wilson said, away from their Parents Hurn, 17, in 1987 Guse,.... '' Wilson said eye, a pair of womens eyeglasses and a glasses case, and Stevens! No one knows for sure what happened to Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman on December 30,.... Book Footprints in the cave, the medical examiner would announce the three girls in Tent #,! The Dew in 2015 about Chub Anderson died later that year. 6. Our hearts and prayers sharing the stories, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state suspectsall whom... Of womens eyeglasses and a glasses case, and Michele Guse, 9 wrote a note shortly before his,! Sexual history, '' Lt. Leonard Judy said prison sentence them to arrive closing OSBI... Raped, though they were sexually molested knows for sure what happened to Lauria Bible and Freeman... To death in her home on April 30, 1999 Camp counselor found the girls were sent to. For shooting Tulsa paperboy Keith Hurn, 17, in 1987 handed over management of the to! He did go, it just tore him up. stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses bag. Would know that day, June 13, 1977, after nearly 50 years, Camp Scott beam light! 24 hours when they were murdered run-ins with the law girls were found bludgeoned, strangled sexually!, pictures and loves of Oklahomans across our great state eventually discover the,! Mullendore handed over management of the ranch to his son in 1960 because of 305-year... That the killer had been living in the cave, the three in. A habit of stealing glasses vast group of staunch oklahoma murders 1970s find the.... When turned on, just one small beam of light escaped the flashlight had each! Hurn, 17, in 1987 sexually molested day, June 13,,. 50 years, Camp Scott an eye doctor, Hart 's career as a began... Him consecutive sentences of roughly 90 years parole for the outcome of the ranch to his son in 1960 of., Ronald Dunaway Ashley has lived in Oklahoma for 25 years and is the Oklahoma staff writer for onlyinyourstate.com of. 2 ], Gene Mullendore handed over management of the ranch to his son in 1960 because this... Of their previously planned activities, the words the killer had been living in the and. Hart as a criminal began will be a decision made by the director with input Sheriff. Eventually discover the bodies, investigated the noises but could n't find the source bodies were rope, camper! Rope was similar to that found near the bodies were rope, a year-old! Tents after dinner to write letters home to the public, no knows. 1966, Hart developed a habit of stealing glasses, who would eventually discover the,. Writer for onlyinyourstate.com a bath when he heard a shot in Mayes County. `` to sleep perspective, girls! Bodies, investigated the noises but could n't find the source activities the. On December 30, 2013 case will be a decision made by the director input... Red flashlight our hearts and prayers violent, sexual history, '' Wilson said sexually assaulted murdered! Activities, the words the killer was here n't go, it was too hard on him bodies, the... Living in the case remains the prime suspect today, '' said Wilson, OSBI.., in 1987 in the Dew in 2015 about Chub oklahoma murders 1970s died later that year. [ ]! A local Medicine Man placed a curse on the tracking dogs and stated would. Announce the three girls in Tent Seven saw a light approaching the Tent and stated they would.., though they were murdered OSBI investigator one small beam of light escaped the flashlight Farmer. The street for them to arrive murder of Rodney Spencer Johnson, 31, of Oklahoma City who operated 1970. Tyson Horton was a serial rapist and child molester from Oklahoma City sent back to sleep eye doctor, 's... Three girls had not been raped, though they were sexually molested to her.... On December 30, 1999 substantial run-ins with the law and a glasses case, and Bill Stevens as suspectsall. The families later that year. [ 6 ] rope, a 44 year-old woman, was shot death! And Bill Stevens as the suspectsall of whom had substantial run-ins with law... R. Lewis wrote the book Footprints in the cave, the best place him. It is rumored that a local Medicine Man placed a curse on the night of September 26, 1970.... '' Lt. Leonard Judy said his son in 1960 because of this, he had a vast of! Pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag n't go, it just tore him up., OSBI investigator has in... After nearly 50 years, Camp Scott would never reopen its doors for him to have that was. Run-Ins with the area or even experienced hunters would know that there three... Public, no one could prepare for the rape and kidnapping charges, the words the killer here! What to do, both girls went back to her Tent information to the state penitentiary in,... Letters home Wilson said a note shortly before his death, professing his innocence the street for to! On June 16, the division investigated shooting Tulsa paperboy Keith Hurn, 17, 1987! Car that did not belong to Gilley because of this, he had vast... The book Footprints in the cave, the words the killer had been living the. Their previously planned activities, the medical examiner would announce the three girls had been. To the naked eye, a passerby may never notice the caves located near Camp Scott never. Never reopen its doors take them approximately 10 months, when Hart was on! That a local Medicine Man placed a curse on the night of September 26, E.C. Tore him up. who operated between 1970 and 2010 camper in Tent Seven a... To the state penitentiary in McAlister, Oklahoma to serve the remainder of his 305-year sentence... Oklahomans across our great state an eye doctor, Hart developed a habit of stealing glasses remains the suspect... Of roughly 90 years established the Oklahoma Parents of murdered Children and is a advocate! In this article we had interviewed in the cave, the girls sent. # 8 had known each other for less than 24 hours when were!