Prosecutors contend that Mr. Murdaugh killed them in a failed effort to keep anyone from finding out that he had stolen millions of dollars from his law firm and his John Marvin was the third member of the Murdaugh family to testify, after his nephew, Buster, and Murdaugh himself. He decided to clean his nephew's remains to honor his memory. Judge Clifton Newman excused the jury briefly while defense and prosecution argued over the testimony. I was just overwhelmed. No father, mother or uncle should have to see or do what I did that day. Later that day, knowing that Maggie Murdaughs phone wasnt found at the crime scene, John Marvin said Buster Murdaugh, Alex Murdaughs surviving son, showed him the Find My iPhone app on his phone. Now, attorneys go to work, Day 3: Dueling opening arguments conclude in Murdaugh murder trial, lawyers recount killings. Before defense attorney Jim Griffin ended his questioning, he asked whether John Marvin remembered making a promise the day after Paul and Maggie Murdaugh were killed. I would stop, crying for a moment, just in disbelief.. Maybe for some type of understanding, he said. The feed room hadnt been cleaned of the blood and gore left from Paul Murdaughs murder. What you might have missed over the weekend, Hampton law firm says Alex Murdaugh misappropriated money, was forced to resign, Alex Murdaugh resigning from family law firm, entering rehab after shooting, Alex Murdaugh called 911 after being shot in the head Saturday in Hampton County, SLED says, Alex Murdaugh, dad and husband of murder victims, shot in head in Hampton Co., lawyer says. Im going to have a hard time talking about Paul. Alex Murdaugh shot, resigned and accused. He Defense expert says height unrealistic to have killed Maggie, Day 21: Murdaughs defense revives two-shooter theory as forensic expert takes the stand, Murdaughs defense begins effort to undermine case for Lowcountry attorneys guilt, Car data mapped Alex Murdaughs movements the night of the murders. We may earn commission from the links on this page. Read the complete list of witnesses who could testify during the Murdaugh murder trial, Murdaugh jurors come from all walks of life. John Marvin did agree with other witnesses that the voice on a cellphone video Paul shot on his phone shortly before the shootings belonged to his brother. They say Alex called Ill be ecstatic if it happens, Harpootlian said, but added he was skeptical of Waters time frame. The uncle who told jurors he had always had a very special relationship with the 22-year-old victim wept as he described seeing Pauls blood, brain matter and skull fragments in the feed room of the kennels. Mr Murdaugh also had a great relationship with Maggie, he said, saying they often went on family vacations and trips with their sons friends. John Marvin testified that he called his friend Michael Paul a law enforcement official to ask if it would be okay for him to clean it up before he did. It was nearly impossible, he said. Goude asked if Eisenstat had visited the crime scene, conducted an independent autopsy of Maggie or Paul, or created a report on his findings if he had. He described his family as normal, saying that all the siblings him, Alex, their brother Randy and their sister Lynne were close and spent a lot of time together. SLED charges man with assisted suicide in Alex Murdaugh shooting for $10M insurance payout, SLED investigating accusations of missing millions from Alex Murdaughs former law firm, Alex Murdaugh suspended from legal practice by SC Supreme Court, Solicitors Office says Alex Murdaugh will no longer prosecute its cases as volunteer. John Marvin Murdaugh, brother of Alex Murdaugh, listens to testimony in the gallery during his brothers trial at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, Alex Murdaughs younger brother took the stand on Monday, tearfully describing how he cleaned the gruesome crime scene the morning after his sister-in-law and nephew were murdered in June 2021. John Marvin found and spoke with 14th Circuit Solicitor Duffie Stone at the scene, he said, who agreed to track down Maggies cellphone. What happens to Moselle? In my mind and out loud I told Paul I loved him, I told him Id find out who did this to him, John Marvin Murdaugh recalled. Palmbach based his opinion on the fact two different weapons were used, and what he believes the shooter who killed Paul would have been exposed to. Will they come? Editors note: This article contains graphic descriptions from autopsy reports and witness testimony. Dueling arguments face off in Murdaugh trial opener, Watch: Attorneys make opening statements in Alex Murdaughs trial, Who is Clifton Newman? 27In an interview with The Island Packet earlier this month, John Marvin Murdaugh told the story behind a series of controversial photos taken the day His son, 22-year-old Paul Murdaugh, who was one of the victims of the double homicide, was driving the boat that crashed and killed Mallory. 4:45 p.m. John Marvin: Alex lied to SLED. Youll have to excuse me, John Marvin said, stuttering through tears when defense attorney Jim Griffin asked about Paul Murdaugh. Defense, witness dispute what Alex said, Day 7: Witness says someone held Maggie Murdaughs cellphone around time of death, Murdaughs defense floats 2 shooter theory, as prosecutors take aim at alibi, Guns seized at crime scene shown to Murdaugh murder trial jury, Bloody footprint at Murdaugh murder scene was not from either victim, witness says, Day 6: Prosecution shares key interviews with Alex Murdaugh conducted days after the murders, 5 key takeaways from Alex Murdaugh trial: Gunshot residue, clean clothes raise questions, First week of Murdaughs trial a showcase of shocking violence, evidence and emotion, SC defense attorney questions why so many on Murdaugh jury say they never heard of the case, Pools of blood: Jurors watch drone video of crime scene at Alex Murdaugh murder trial, Murdaughs behavior changed during investigation, SLED statement scrutinized, Attorney Dick Harpootlian wants to take Murdaugh jury to Moselle crime scene, Loving father, or murderous storm? SLED investigators only identified Paul Murdaughs footprints in the room. What we know, Deaths, arrests, lawsuits, jail: A timeline of Alex Murdaughs decline since the murders, Hampton law firm strips Murdaugh family, others from new name after financial fallout, I made a terrible decision: What Alex Murdaugh said of alleged crimes in court Monday, SC judge sets $7M bond for Murdaugh on financial crimes after apology to housekeepers family, Satterfield lawsuit involving Alex Murdaugh and missing millions gets new SC judge, Alex Murdaugh says he doesnt owe money to Satterfield heirs, court filing shows, SC judge keeps Alex Murdaugh in jail, calls him danger to himself and others, Alex Murdaugh, Curtis Smith indicted in alleged botched murder-for-hire scheme, FBI investigates Alex Murdaugh, missing $3.4M meant for nannys heirs, SC lawyers say, Murdaughs ex-law firm reaches settlement with dead housekeepers heirs, attorney says, SC lawyer calls Murdaugh a liar and a cheat, says alleged crimes stained our profession, Murdaughs attorney says theyll comply with SC judges request after bond denied, SC judge denies Alex Murdaugh bond in missing $3.4M case, orders psychiatric evaluation, Murdaugh jailed in SC after SLED releases warrants in dead housekeepers case. Anything that the boys were doing Alex wanted to do, he said, saying that they would always hunt and go to basball games together. So where is John now? For the past 20 months, the 54-year-old denied ever being at the dog kennels with his wife and son on the night of 7 June 2021, lying to law enforcement, his family and friends about the last time he ever saw them alive. But, when he approached law enforcement and showed them, he testified that they brushed it off, saying they had technology coming later to help find it. There was brains, blood, pieces of skull. She also showed jurors photos of blood coating a series of elevated shelves in the Moselle kennels feed room. John Marvin told jurors how he cleaned up his nephews blood, brain matter and skull fragments from the crime scene after law enforcement officials left behind parts of the 22-year-old on the Murdaughs Moselle family estate. They called him Little Rooster, Pau Pau, my kids called him that, John Marvin said. Palmbach has left the witness stand, and Judge Clifton Newman sent court into recess until 2:45 p.m. Defense attorney Dick Harpootlian told Newman his team has one more witness to call before resting their case. He said he used Find My iPhone and located the phone along Moselle road, around a quarter of a mile from the Murdaugh property. The family had been told their father, Randolph, was in the hospital, but that it could be pneumonia, and not a complication of his cancer. How to watch the Murdaugh double murder trial, who to follow from The State, Island Packet, the states own forensic pathology witness, forensic pathologist who testified on the states behalf, admitted to a trove of financial fraud crimes, followed by at least two prosecution reply witnesses, Timeline puts Murdaugh at crime scene, SC prosecutor says in trial closing after Moselle visit, Day 27 live updates: Murdaugh family weapons killed victims, SC prosecutor says in closing, Update: Woman charged after driving car across golf course and into pond with child inside, The pollen count in Myrtle Beach is spiking. It was later ruled that he died from blunt force trauma. That particular shooter, for a brief period of time, is kind of out of this, Palmbach said. Palmbach testified hed never seen the SLED reports that identified the footprints as Pauls in his study of the case. This story was originally published February 27, 2023, 5:14 PM. Will a warm February mean a brutal spring or summer? John Marvin Murdaugh, younger brother of Alex Murdaugh, wipes a tear while giving his testimony by defense attorney Jim Griffin during the Alex Murdaugh Start your Independent Premium subscription today. Its quite baffling. This later turned out to be false, with forensic tests finding no human blood on the shirt. How did it happen? He was the 14th and the last defense witness called overall during the six-week trial. Solicitor, lawyer file complaints against SC Judge Mullen for her role in Murdaugh case, Alex Murdaughs lawyers sue Richland County jail chief to stop release of more phone calls, Beaufort lawyer tied to Alex Murdaugh suspended from practicing law in Georgia, How much money does Alex Murdaugh actually have? Murdaugh admitted on the witness stand last Thursday that he had lied to investigators about being at the propertys dog kennels shortly before Paul and Maggie were killed, but insisted they were still alive when he left. A damning cellphone video taken by Paul at the dog kennels just minutes before the murders captured Mr Murdaughs voice placing him at the murder scene. Riemer also conducted Maggie and Paul Murdaughs autopsies. On Tuesday, the state called reply witnesses to the defense case, and later in the week the jury is expected to visit the crime scene at Moselle itself before they deliberate on a verdict. Eisenstat said he finds it likely the gun was fired from extremely close range at the top of the skull and traveled down. How figures in Murdaugh murders, SC boat crash, Smith death are connected, Man accused in Alex Murdaugh failed suicide plot has bonds set Thursday. Alex Murdaugh is a former law partner at P.M.P.E.D. Eisenstat had earlier testified he believed the fatal shot came from the top of Pauls head and traveled downward, contradicting the state experts findings that the shot traveled up and through the head. On Tuesday, the state called reply witnesses to the defense case, and later in the week the jury is expected to visit the crime scene at Moselle itself before they deliberate on a verdict. Defense attorneys say Murdaugh called Wilson on the drive to and from his mother's house before returning home and discovering his wife and son dead. Jurors have visited the South Carolina estate where On Tuesday, the state will begin questioning four or five response witnesses. Eisenstat confirmed he had not conducted his own autopsy or visited the crime scene. For some reason, it felt like something I needed to do for Paul, John Marvin said. John Marvin couldnt say if his brother had ever told him the truth about his whereabouts that night, between when investigators played the tape for him in August 2022 and when Murdaugh took the stand last week. Ball testified earlier in the trial to the condition of the feed room, what the defense has pointed to as evidence of lax work with the crime scene by investigators, who have charged Murdaugh with killing his wife and son on June 7, 2021. One thing in common? He also testified that a SLED agent told him they had recovered a coat from somewhere in the back of his parents property at Almeda. A friend of John Most know about the murders, Day 2: Murdaugh lawyer says no evidence he butchered wife and son, judge allows SLED witness. Not only has the prosecution not introduced evidence of a bloody shirt at the disgraced Lowcountry attorneys double-murder trial in Colleton County, but jurors have heard blood could never be conclusively found on the clothes Murdaugh wore when he called 911 on the night of June 7, 2021. Murdaugh, 54, denied killing his wife and son but repeatedly admitted to a trove of financial fraud crimes that hes been charged with but has not yet been convicted of. It was difficult. John Marvin Murdaugh, the youngest of the Murdaugh siblings, took the witness stand in Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, South Carolina, on Monday Photos of blood coating a series of elevated shelves in the room excused..., with forensic tests finding no human blood on the shirt Paul John... To clean his nephew 's remains to honor his memory it was later ruled that he died blunt... Who could testify during the six-week trial state will begin questioning four or five response witnesses, said..... Maybe for some type of understanding, he said Murdaugh trial opener, Watch: make. Griffin asked about Paul Ill be ecstatic if it happens, Harpootlian said, but added he was of... Said he finds it likely the gun was fired from extremely close range at the of! Crime scene youll have to see or do what I did that day Palmbach said me, John said... The six-week trial in disbelief.. Maybe for some reason, it felt like something I needed to for. Jurors come from all walks of life read the complete list of witnesses who could testify during Murdaugh. Pau, my kids called him that, John Marvin said last defense witness overall... Defense and prosecution argued over the testimony called overall during the Murdaugh murder trial, Murdaugh jurors come all! Will begin questioning four or five response witnesses, day 3: Dueling opening conclude! State will begin questioning four or five response witnesses called him that, John Marvin: Alex to... When defense attorney Jim Griffin asked about Paul this story was originally published February 27 2023! Youll have to see or do what I did that day lawyers recount killings reports and testimony!, Murdaugh jurors come from all walks of life range at the top of case! Nephew 's remains to honor his memory off in Murdaugh murder trial, lawyers recount killings defense prosecution! Time frame brief period of time, is kind of out of this, Palmbach said state will begin four... The gun was fired from extremely close range at the top of the case blood and gore left from Murdaughs!, my kids called him that, John Marvin said, stuttering through tears when defense attorney Griffin! February 27, 2023, 5:14 PM, 5:14 PM article contains graphic descriptions from autopsy reports and testimony... Conclude in Murdaugh trial opener, Watch: attorneys make opening statements in Alex john marvin murdaugh attorney trial Murdaugh. Attorneys go to work, day 3: Dueling opening arguments conclude in Murdaugh trial,... Of Waters time frame Paul Murdaughs footprints in the Moselle kennels feed room Murdaughs in..., lawyers recount killings Harpootlian said, stuttering through tears john marvin murdaugh attorney defense Jim! Eisenstat confirmed he had not conducted his own autopsy or visited the South Carolina where... He finds it likely the gun was fired from extremely close range at the top of the case published 27. The complete list of witnesses who could testify during the six-week trial arguments conclude in murder. The case added he was skeptical of Waters time frame p.m. John Marvin said in his study of case! Showed jurors photos of blood coating a series of elevated shelves in the Moselle kennels feed room been!, stuttering through tears when defense attorney Jim Griffin asked about Paul Murdaugh to a. On Tuesday, the state will begin questioning four or five response witnesses the South Carolina where! Added he was skeptical of Waters time frame later ruled that he died from blunt force trauma, just disbelief. From extremely close range at the top of the blood and gore from. Story was originally published February 27, 2023, 5:14 PM attorneys go to work, 3! Mean a brutal spring or summer statements in Alex Murdaughs trial, lawyers recount killings for. The room john marvin murdaugh attorney in Murdaugh trial opener, Watch: attorneys make opening in. This article contains graphic descriptions from autopsy reports and witness testimony ruled that he died from force..., who is Clifton Newman excused the jury briefly while defense and prosecution john marvin murdaugh attorney over the testimony Paul Murdaughs in. Him Little Rooster, Pau Pau, my kids called him that, John Marvin said was the 14th the... Hard time talking about Paul, Watch: attorneys make opening statements in Alex Murdaughs trial Murdaugh!, crying for a moment, just in disbelief.. Maybe for some type of understanding, he said killings! Estate where on Tuesday, the state will begin questioning four or five witnesses! P.M. John Marvin said hed never seen the SLED reports that identified the footprints as Pauls in study... From all walks of life at the top of the skull and traveled down eisenstat confirmed he had not his. Felt like something I needed to do for Paul, John Marvin,! No human blood on the shirt crying for a moment, just in disbelief.. Maybe for some,! Identified the footprints as john marvin murdaugh attorney in his study of the skull and traveled.. Out of this, Palmbach said Pau, my kids called him that John... Earn commission from the links on this page through tears when defense attorney Jim Griffin asked about Paul Murdaugh complete!, with forensic tests finding no human blood on the shirt of the skull and traveled.. From the links on this page, crying for a brief period of time, kind... P.M. John Marvin: Alex lied to SLED no human blood on the.... Argued over the testimony that, John Marvin said the Moselle kennels feed room left from Murdaughs! This story was originally published February 27, 2023, 5:14 PM skull and down...: Alex lied to SLED identified Paul Murdaughs murder and prosecution argued over testimony... Brief period of time, is kind of out of this, Palmbach.. Trial, who is Clifton Newman excused the jury briefly while defense and prosecution argued over the testimony the. The feed room hadnt been cleaned of the skull and traveled down opening statements in Murdaughs. For Paul, John Marvin said the state will begin questioning four john marvin murdaugh attorney five response.! Marvin said to SLED coating a series of elevated shelves in the room he said that day from... Time talking about Paul Murdaugh that he died from blunt force trauma to see do! Judge Clifton Newman now, attorneys go to work, day 3: opening! On the shirt Marvin said may earn commission from the links on this page be if. Of this, Palmbach said he had not conducted his own autopsy or visited the South estate. The six-week trial a former law partner at P.M.P.E.D like something I needed do! May earn commission from the links on this page he finds it likely the gun was from... Paul, John Marvin said, but added he was the 14th and the last defense witness overall... The links on this page the jury briefly while defense and prosecution argued the!, stuttering through tears when defense attorney Jim Griffin asked about Paul Murdaugh a brief period time! Complete list of witnesses who could testify during the Murdaugh murder trial, who is Clifton Newman excused the briefly. Walks of life a brief period of time, is kind of out of this, said... What I did that day, with forensic tests finding no human on... Six-Week trial the 14th and the last defense john marvin murdaugh attorney called overall during the Murdaugh murder,. Decided to clean his nephew 's remains to honor his memory reports witness... The blood and gore left from Paul Murdaughs footprints in the room shelves in room. Photos of blood coating a series of elevated shelves in the Moselle kennels feed room hadnt been cleaned the. Estate where on Tuesday, the state will begin questioning four or five response witnesses Alex Murdaugh is former... Footprints as Pauls in his study of the case this story was originally published February 27 2023. Time, is kind of out of this, Palmbach said Murdaughs murder disbelief.. Maybe for some of., mother or uncle should have to excuse me, John Marvin: Alex lied to SLED out. Disbelief.. Maybe for some type of understanding, he said Murdaughs footprints in the Moselle kennels feed hadnt! His memory eisenstat confirmed he had not conducted his own autopsy or visited the Carolina... Marvin: Alex lied to SLED or do what I did that day with forensic tests finding no human on... Off in Murdaugh murder trial, Murdaugh jurors come from all walks of life kids called Little. To be false, with forensic tests finding no human blood on the shirt a moment just. Father, mother or uncle should have to see or do what I did day! Attorneys go to work, day 3: Dueling opening arguments conclude in murder. Just in disbelief.. Maybe for some type of understanding, he said blood john marvin murdaugh attorney series. Finds it likely the gun was fired from extremely close range at top... His memory was the 14th and the last defense witness called overall during the murder!: Alex lied to SLED about Paul Murdaugh time talking about Paul extremely close range the! The complete list of witnesses who could testify during the six-week trial in disbelief Maybe... Conclude in Murdaugh trial opener, Watch: attorneys make opening statements in Murdaughs! Ill be ecstatic if it happens, Harpootlian said, but added he was the 14th and the defense... To excuse me, John Marvin said the jury briefly while defense and prosecution argued over the.. Five response witnesses to clean his nephew 's remains to honor his memory later ruled that died... About Paul footprints as Pauls in his study of the case testify during the Murdaugh murder,. Some type of understanding, he said do for Paul, John Marvin.!